MORE MONEY, FEWER LENDERS: WHAT ARIZONA’S Q3 LENDING DATA TELLS ME
Every quarter I look at recorded loan data for Arizona private lenders. Q3 showed a shift I think every private lending investor should understand.

The money went up. The number of lenders went down.
Private-lender loan volume in Arizona reached $2.08B in Q3, up 14% year over year. Year to date it is $5.64B, also up 14%.
Short-term loans in Maricopa County, our best stand-in for fix-and-flip and bridge lending, rose 16% in count and 23% in dollars.
But the number of active private lenders in Arizona fell from 493 to 435. That is 58 fewer, a 12% decline.
Lenders that specialize in flips and ground-up construction made 22% and 29% fewer loans than a year ago.
More capital is flowing through fewer lenders. And the specialists, the ones closest to the work, are the ones shrinking.
Why Lenders Are Leaving
The flip business itself is tighter. ATTOM’s latest report shows the typical U.S. flip earned a 21.5% gross margin last quarter, down from 27.6% a year ago. That is before rehab, holding, and selling costs, which usually run 20 to 33% of the after-repair value. For many flips, the real profit is now in the single digits.
Texas shows how bad it can get. In Dallas, the typical flip earned 1.8% gross. In Austin, 2.8%. In San Antonio, it lost money. When borrowers’ margins disappear, lenders who underwrote loosely get hurt first, and the ones without staying power exit.
Add a Fed that raised rates in September, with one more hike likely, and a Phoenix market where supply is climbing. Thin margins and slower sales are when underwriting gets tested.
What I Take From It
In football, you learn quickly that the scheme matters less than the fundamentals. The teams still standing in January are not the ones with the flashiest playbook. They are the ones that block and tackle every single down.
Lending is the same. Here are the fundamentals I am watching harder right now.
Leverage is your margin of safety. When a borrower’s spread shrinks, the lender’s cushion has to come from the loan-to-value. Our book sits around 46% loan-to-after-repair-value. If a flip sells for 20% less than projected, we are still well covered.
Price point matters. ATTOM’s data shows the strongest flip margins on homes bought for 100K to 300K (26 to 28%). The weakest margins are at the very low end and in overheated metros. Knowing which part of the market you are lending into matters more than the headline rate.
Local knowledge is an edge. National lenders price Phoenix off the same model they use for Dallas. The data says those are very different markets right now. I would rather know every street in the Valley than know a little about 30 states.
Being there matters. As lenders exit, the good borrowers, experienced operators with real track records, are looking for someone who will still be there next year. That is a better pool of borrowers for a disciplined lender.
The Takeaway
The opportunity in private lending right now is not more volume. It is better selection. Margins are tighter for everyone. The lenders who do well will be the ones who said no more often.
If you want to talk through how to evaluate a lender’s underwriting, reply to this email. I read every response.
Newsletter Edition #217



Comments